To sum it all up, NIWA can't help anything grow if people think it's our fertilizer and reject it on the first visit, so yeah, we ought to reject every startup application on the first submission and list things they need to do beforehand-minor things mainly. And the most important part, talk to them, and/or help them.
This would be a very bad idea. NIWA should already have more wikis than what we currently have. But, yet, it's that type of attitude
(i.e. waiting for the "perfect" wiki to come along) that lead us to our current state. I think rejecting a new submission to list things that they need to improve on and wait on them to reapply basically defeats the purpose of NIWA.